Out Of Hundreds Of Fluffy Down Comforters, These 19 Are Worth The Investment
When the pipes start clanging in our apartment buildings, the fleece clothing gets unpacked, and the space heaters are pulled out from their under-bed hiding spots. We know what’s here: winter. During the seasonal swap, we often make a change of bedding, replacing our lightweight summer quilts with the best comforters. A warm and cozy sleep atmosphere does not always translate to a hot and heavy bed — it just takes investing in a comforter that will keep you snuggled up while also regulating your body temperature.
Down and down alternative comforters offer excellent insulation by trapping breathable heat. It offers warmth without weighing you down while you catch your cold-weather ZZZs. We looked at hundreds of options — from sustainable down and goose to hypoallergenic alternatives — in order to pull out the 19 best comforters that come reviewer-tested and approved. Keep clicking to find the one that’s right for you and your bed during these chilly months.
At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. All product details reflect the price and availability at the time of publication. If you buy or click on something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.
Welcome to Hype Machine, our hit-list of the top reviewed products and travel experiences across the web — according to a crowd of die-hard shoppers. Call this your 4-star-and-up club, with entry granted by our devoted-to-the-goods editors.
For more can’t-miss shopping stories delivered straight to your inbox, sign up for our Most Wanted newsletter.
End of winter intro
Winter has nearly ended, but the cold weather and all its frills — space heaters, extra layers, and warm blankets — are still going strong. During this transitional period, one thing is for sure: We need some solid bedding (think snuggly comforters instead of lightweight summer quilts). But, a warm-and-cozy sleep atmosphere does not always translate to a hot-and-heavy bed — it just takes investing in the right style of comforter to keep you snuggled up while also regulating your body temperature.
Quince Premium Down Alternative Lightweight Comforter, $, available at Quince
Sunday Citizen Snug Stitch Comforter
The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars and 55 reviews on Sundaycitizen.com
Not only are Sunday Citizen’s colorful comforters beloved by customers, but according to this product’s on-site description, over 2.1 million plastic water bottles have been recycled for these duvet inserts. If you love a sustainable find, then consider what on-site reviewer Krystin T. has to say. She writes, “We love this comforter! The inside lining is so cooling, and it’s the softest bedding we’ve ever had. We went on vacation and we kept saying we couldn’t wait to get back in our own bed because we missed our bedding.”
Shop Sunday Citizen
Sunday Citizen Snug Stitch Comforter, $, available at Sunday Citizen
Boll & Branch Down Alternative Duvet Insert
The Hype: 4.8 out of 5 stars and 639 reviews on Bollandbranch.com
According to one Boll & Branch reviewer, this comforter — featuring three weight options, hypoallergenic fibers, and 100% organic cotton — is some “luxurious bedding.” They “love how this duvet insert stays fluffy” and keeps them “at a perfect temperature (paired with flannel sheets) as it gets colder.”
Shop Boll & Branch
Boll & Branch Down Alternative Duvet Insert, $, available at Boll & Branch
Double Stitch Down Duvet Insert
The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars and 9 reviews on Doublestitch.com
Premium bedding brand Double Stitch just recently stepped onto the scene with the help of its beloved parent company Bedsure. On its site, you’ll find all kinds of cozy home upgrades — from sheet sets to duvet covers and, of course, quality comforters. Despite being barely a month old, the Double Stitch Down Duvet Insert is already one to watch. “This comforter with a white 100% cotton outer shell is lightweight, soft, breathable,” says on-site reviewer Corinna. “I feel so comfortable sleeping with it. It fits my queen-size bed perfectly,” she adds.
Shop Double Stitch
Double Stitch Down Duvet Insert, $, available at Double Stitch
Quince Premium Down Alternative Lightweight Comforter
The Hype: 4.9 out of 5 stars and 1,047 reviews on Quince.com
Feel like sleeping in a cloud? This down alternative comforter from Quince has got you covered…literally. It’s filled with hypoallergenic microfiber, covered in 100% cotton, and specifically constructed to be extra-fluffy.
On-site reviewer Lauren K. attests to its cushiony stature. “Legit feels like sleeping in clouds,” she mentions. “My senior dog also loves it…she likes to burrow herself under it for long naps. 🙂 Human- AND dog-approved.”
Shop Quince
Quince Premium Down Alternative Comforter, $, available at Quince
Saatva All-Year Down Alternative Comforter
The Hype: 4.8 out of 5 stars and 9 reviews on Saatva.com
Saatva’s all-weather comforter is made with a blend of breathable down alternative, sustainable Lyocell, and fair trade-certified cotton. Plus, it’s both temperature-regulating and hypoallergenic.
Saatva reviewer, Dorothy, explains, “I’m getting much better sleep now with this comforter. It’s fluffy, crisp, and warm, but not too warm. I feel like I’m in a luxurious hotel every time I get into bed! I love that this is made ethically and without yucky chemicals. Overall I’m really pleased with the quality, and while I balked at the price initially, I definitely think it’s worth every penny now that I’ve been using this comforter daily.”
Shop Saatva
Saatva All-Year Down Alternative Comforter, $, available at Saatva
Buffy Cloud Comforter
The Hype: 4.8 out of 5 stars and 23,540 reviews on Buffy.com
You’ve probably already heard about Buffy, but have you tried the cloud comforter? One verified buyer Alex B. did, and says he “[gets] underneath the comforter and [falls] asleep almost instantly.” It has that fluffy name for a reason. Plus, the company aims to make you feel as comfortable as possible without making our home base planet Earth uncomfy.
The website states: “Each Buffy Cloud Comforter keeps 50 plastic bottles out of landfill thanks to 100% recycled, extra-fluffy fill sourced in Estonia.”
Shop Buffy
Buffy Cloud Comforter, $, available at Buffy
Parachute All Season Down Duvet Insert
The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars and 587 reviews on Parachutehome.com
Parachute’s down comforter provides generous coverage — you know, so you won’t have to fight for warmth when sleeping beside your partner. It’s so good that it urged one reviewer to write a rare review.
“I don’t often write reviews, but I LOVE our Parachute comforter,” Kelly says. “It’s light and fluffy, evenly filled, perfectly warm, but not too hot.” Transform your bed into cloud-like comfort with 750 European white down-filled fluffiness. If you live in a warmer location, the lightweight fabrication is ideal for icy, air-conditioned bedrooms.
Shop Parachute
Parachute All Season Down Duvet Insert, $, available at Parachute
Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter
The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars and 1,883 reviews on Brooklinen.com
If you’re on the hunt for a down comforter that can be used in both summer and winter, you’ve come to the right place. Brooklinen’s all-season option is perfect for warm sleepers. It’s filled with its 100% cotton shell fabric that’s described by Brooklinen as “ultra-soft.”
Reviewers concur. Eunice L., is “happy with [his] purchase,” as he “was able to use it in the summer and it wasn’t too hot.” Five out of five stars.
For a limited time get 20% off sitewide.
Shop Brooklinen
Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter, $, available at Brooklinen
Sijo AiryWeight Eucalyptus Comforter
The Hype: 4.8 out of 5 stars and 141 reviews on Sijohome.com
Our lifestyle writer Alexandra Polk swears by her Sijo Home Eucalyptus Comforter. Sijo Home reviewer Alex M. refers to it as “the best one that [they’ve] found!” The bedding’s biggest selling point? It features major cooling capabilities, thanks to its 100% Tencel Lyocell fibers blended with, per its description, “sustainably farmed eucalyptus.” And don’t be afraid of its thin, lightweight style. Even Polk, a notoriously cold sleeper, feels “snug as a bug” with her comforter all night long.
Shop Sijo
Sijo AiryWeight Eucalyptus Comforter, $, available at Sijo
Joss & Main Winter Down Alternative Comforter
The Hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars and 3,516 reviews on Jossandmain.com
This down alternative comforter is made for all-season use and for those who suffer from allergies. Its hypoallergenic microfiber fill keeps you cozy in the chilly months but is still breathable, so it’s suitable for use in the warmer months. According to Joss & Main reviewer Barbara, it’s “the perfect weight and it has corner loops to secure a duvet cover.”
Shop Joss & Main
Joss & Main Winter Down Alternative Comforter, $, available at Joss & Main
Enchante Home Down Alternative Climate Comforter
The Hype: 4.9 out of 5 stars and 32 reviews on NordstromRack.com
This down alternative comforter is designed with air channels for air circulation and even temperature distribution, so you’ll stay toasty warm without overheating. For one customer, Adriana, it “keeps [her] warm enough at where [she’s] not overheating!”
Shop Nordstrom Rack
Enchante Home Down Alternative King Size Climate Comforter, $, available at Nordstrom Rack
Coyuchi Climate Beneficial Wool Duvet Insert
The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars and 93 reviews on Coyuchi.com
This unique duvet by Coyuchi is made with organic wool batting inside. Unlike a traditional down fill, this option is naturally hypoallergenic, and it will keep you cool in the summer and toasty in the winter.
On-site reviewer Emily D. confirms that this investment is worth it. “This comforter insert is absolutely fabulous. Wool is wonderful — it has a much more streamlined look than down and it always seems to be just the right amount of insulation; light but it keeps you warm.”
Shop Coyuchi
Coyuchi Climate Beneficial Wool Duvet Insert, $, available at Coyuchi
L.L. Bean Sateen White Goose Down Comforter
The Hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars and 91 reviews on LLBean.com
If warm luxury is what you’re after, scroll no further. For cold locations and frigid winters, L.L. Bean’s goose-down comforter is made of 700-fill power with a thread count promising silky smoothness. The oversized silhouette promises coverage while the sateen composition adds a baby-butt-soft feel. After trying and returning many down comforters, L.L. Bean reviewer KitL says that they are “so glad [they] did,” exclaiming how “this comforter is perfect. It doesn’t make a rustling sound as others did. It’s big and fluffy, making my bed so luxurious. I have a flannel duvet cover and it makes the perfect combination. I LOVE to go to bed at night.” Talk about a comfy haven.
Shop L.L. Bean
L.L. Bean Sateen White Goose Down Comforter, Warmer, $, available at L.L. Bean
Ettitude Down Alternative Comforter
The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars and 132 reviews on Ettitude.com
An Ettitude reviewer applauds the brand’s Down Alternative Comforter for being “not too heavy but not too light” and the reason that she stays the “perfect temperature” all night long. So why not complete your cozy bedroom setup with a super-fluffy duvet stuffed with soft organic bamboo fibers? Mindfully designed, it’s more breathable compared to polyester filling.
Shop Ettitude
Ettitude Down Alternative Comforter, $, available at Ettitude
FluffCo Down Blended Comforter
The Hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars and 213 reviews on Fluff.Co
FluffCo’s plush bedding gives you that luxury-hotel quality minus the luxury-hotel price tag. Crafted with a thoughtful blend of down and ethically sourced temperature-regulating fibers, the brand’s top-rated comforter is a fan favorite for the comfiest and coolest slumbers. FluffCo reviewer Melina, for example, applauds it for being “soooo comfortable” and because it “keeps [her] at perfect temperature” all night long.
FluffCo is currently offering 20% off sitewide at its Holiday Sale.
Shop FluffCo
FluffCo Down Blended Comforter, $, available at FluffCo
SOL Organics Organic Cotton All Season Down Comforter
The Hype: 4.8 out of 5 stars and 211 reviews on SOLOrganix.com
Responsibly sourced and filled with hypoallergenic Canadian down, SOL Organics’ iteration is ideal for cold sleepers, and bundle-lovers who prefer the heat cranked and their products organic. That being said, you won’t overheat. “That is my second comforter,” says one SOL Organics reviewer, “I liked the 700 fill so much that ordered the 600 as well. Amazing, light, warm, and not hot.”
Shop SOL Organics
SOL Organics All Season Down Comforter, $, available at SOL Organics
Alwyn Home All Season Polyester Down Alternative Comforter
The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars and 14,933 reviews on Wayfair.com
Stay cool during the summer and toasty during the winter months with Alwyn Home’s alternative down comforter. Crafted from microfiber, this hypoallergenic style features a secure box stitch to prevent the fill from shifting as you hit snooze over and over.
One Wayfair reviewer in Florida claims it’s not only the “perfect” blanket, but it’s also “soft, fluffy, and lightweight.” Another happy customer, Lisa, chimed in that, “the quality is great for the price point.”
Shop Wayfair
Alwyn Home All Season Polyester Down Alternative Comforter, $, available at Wayfair
Bedsure All Season Down Alternative Comforter
The Hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars and 62,090 reviews on Amazon.com
Bedsure’s All Season Down Alternative Comforter makes any bedroom a cozy sanctuary with premium 300 GSM whole-piece polyester fill covered in a 100% microfiber shell and corner tabs to keep it in place — all for under $50!
Reviewer Kathy J notes how she “love[s] this duvet. It washes up easily and is sewn in a way that all the filling stays in place and doesn’t shift around. I also use the dryer on a medium to dry it and it stays fluffy.” She discloses that while “it’s a bit heavy for summer use [she’s] using it anyways,” saying how “it’s an all-weather duvet but I would say it’s more for colder seasons. It has spots to tie it all into the duvet cover so it doesn’t move around. It’s so soft yet has a good weight so it lays on you without gaps and cold spots. It’s like a big fluffy hug! Perfect. I’ll be buying another one for my husband.”
Shop Bedsure
Bedsure All Season Down Alternative Queen Size Bedding Comforte, $, available at Amazon
Utopia Quilted Comforter Insert
The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars and 114,210 ratings on Amazon.com
This quilted down comforter is both luxe-feeling and affordable, so it’s a total win-win. Amazon reviewer Kylie writes, “This cloud-like duvet is SO comfortable and soft. It is light and heavy at the same time, and you feel that sense of security that a blanket gives you.” And, if its 100,000+ other ratings are any indication of its charm, we think it’s time to cuddle with this fiber-filled, cloud-shaped comforter.
Shop Amazon
Utopia Bedding Quilted Comforter Insert, $, available at Amazon
Kathy Ireland Goose Feather Down Comforter
Wake up feeling chilly every morning? Let’s put that to rest, literally. Layer your bed in luxury with this heavyweight down comforter, filled with goose feathers and cozy comfort. It looks equally as good by itself, or inside a chic duvet.
The Hype: 4.3 out of 5 stars and 858 reviews on Bed, Bath & Beyond
Comfort Seekers Say: “I’ve spent hundreds of dollars on king goose down comforters. This one is as nice or better for 25% of what I’ve spent in the past! I’m going to buy an extra one.” –– Rose, Bed Bath & Beyond Reviewer
Shop Bed, Bath & Beyond
Kathy Ireland White Goose Feather Down Comforter, $, available at Bed Bath and Beyond
Linenspa All-Season Alternative Down Comforter
Can you believe Linenspa’s comforter is only $35? Most can’t. Available in reversible colors, this alternative down is filled with ultra-cozy microfiber with box stitching that keeps the fill securely in place. Need to know more? The reviews speak for themselves.
The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars and 102,600 reviews on Amazon
Comfort Seekers Say: “This comforter is amazing! I was getting too warm with my down comforter but still wanted something soft, and this was the answer. It’s very light, yet still provides enough warmth that I’m only using this with a flat sheet.” –– Joiseygirl, Amazon Reviewer
Shop Amazon
Linenspa All-Season Alternative Down Comforter, $, available at Amazon
Winter Intro
– use when its the beginning of winter
When the pipes start clanging in our apartment buildings, the fleece clothing gets unpacked, and the space heaters are pulled out from their under-bed hiding spots. We know what’s here: winter. During the seasonal swap, we often make a change of bedding: replacing our lightweight summer quilts with snuggly comforters. A warm-and-cozy sleep atmosphere does not always translate to a hot-and-heavy bed — it just takes investing in the right style of comforter that will keep you snuggled up while also regulating your body temperature.
Down and down alternative comforters offer excellent insulation by trapping breathable heat that offers warmness without weighing you down while you catch your cold-weather ZZZs. We looked at hundreds of comforters — from sustainable down and goose to hypoallergenic alternatives — in order to pull out the 16 top-rated options that come reviewer-tested and approved. Keep clicking to find the one that’s right for you and your bed during the chilly months ahead.
Linenspa All-Season Alternative Down Comforter, $, available at Amazon
Riley All Season Down Alternative Comforter
The Hype: 4.8 out of 5 stars and 122 reviews on Rileyhome.com
We love Riley’s goose comforter, and according to reviews, we’ll love the down alternative comforter just as much! Much like its goose counterpart, this one has multiple awards and reviews confirming it will keep you comfortable until next summer.
Riley reviewer Brianna L. writes, “Well-made insert that is just as fluffy as down. The all-season version seems like it’ll be great to use even in the warmer months.”
Shop Riley
Riley Home Down Alternative Comforter, $, available at Riley Home
Riley All Season White Goose Down Comforter
UNHIDE WHEN BACK IN SYOVK
The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars and 856 reviews on Riley
Riley’s goose-down comforter is worth the investment — it’s received awards from multiple prestigious consumer organizations and has five-star reviews aplenty.
Riley reviewer Brianna L. writes, “It’s like sleeping under a cloud and is perfect for moderate northern California temperatures, all year round.” She adds that “it’s durable, functional, and an all-around great buy.” As it is filled with high-quality European goose down, this inviting bedding basic is crafted to prevent shifting and to ensure steady distribution with its tailored baffle box silhouette.
Shop Riley
Riley Home All Season White Goose Down Comforter, $, available at Riley Home
Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?
I Tried Quince's Affordable Linen Duvet Cover Set
The Best Sustainable Bedding Brands
The Internet's Best Duvet Covers
Source link
